We had 5 knocks on our door last night. 5. Five. On the other end of the stick, my kids only had doors opened to them at 3 houses on our street. Where is Halloween Going? Or maybe I should be asking, where has Halloween gone?
I know one place it is dissapearing. In Utah, there is this strange phenomenon called "
Trunk-or-Treat." If you do a quick 'google' search and then click on the
images tab you will easily see that this phenomenon is spreading quickly. Now, this is my 7th Halloween as a Mom and I understand the answers that will come in relation to my question. I understand the fear that has swept the parents of my kids' generation off of their feet. Fear of pedophiles, poisened candy, drunk-drivers...I understand all of that, but I think that the foundations of this fear has been forgotten and in the process, and we have to ask ourselves, we are literally killing a cultural celebration? Are we promoting laziness? What is this all about?
The demise of Halloween trick-or-treating began during the fall of 2001. Do you remember? I was pregenant with my first baby and though I didn't
see the effect that Sept. 11th had on
Halloween I can remember the talking. No one wanted to go Trick-or-Treating. Even halloween parties were stretching it. Everyone was still raw with the hurt that those cowards inflicted upon our nation when they hijacked four airliners. People stayed inside and their celebrations were muted, at best. Here, in an article from a newspaper in Berkeley Newspaper you can read a perfect example of how the entire nation felt about the holiday.
To read how parents felt about Halloween in 2001 CLICK HERE.
Anthrax, terrorists, fear was at it's highest point in years.
ANY alternitive to Trick-or-Treating seemed like a good alternitive.
Next came Halloween 2002. The kids were kept inside, again. This year, however, it was due to fresh memories of a sniper attack in Washington D.C.
To read one Man's observations of Halloween in 2002 CLICK HERE
Halloween in 2003 was snowy here in Utah. Our church congregation had a Halloween party that included trick-or-treating. I took our oldest who was then 18 months old and we had a wonderful time. My husband worked nights at the time and I was 6 months pregenant with our second. This party was a great option for our family, well, at least for me. I was tired and felt the usual obligation to give my child the kind of memories that I had grown up with. This party was such a relief, I have to think that most parents felt that way about the alternitives that presented themselves after Sept. 11, 2001. Easy, quick, fun for the kids, warm. To say nothing of the 18 inches of snow that had landed in Utah that day.
Halloween in 2004 was our first in Clinton, UT. and we were excited to be going Trick-or-Treating. We spent this year with my brother and sister in law a few miles south in Farmington, UT. For that year, as well as the next two years our congregation held what has become known as a "Trunk-or-Treat" but in 2005 and 2006 we opted to stay in our neighborhood and visit our neighbors. The population in our neighboorhood largely consisted of familes that were
not members of the LDS church but as my research has discovered, this is more than likely just the luck of the draw. We had a fun time, there were dozens of families marching house to house, tons of inflatable decorations, and lots and lots of...what else? CANDY!!
What on earth is a Trunk-or-Treat? It varies from place to place but generally consists of everyone pulling into the church parking-lot with the backs of their cars facing inward. When the signal is given the kids then walk from car to car to get their candy. Some congregations really get into it and the individual vehicles decorate the backs of their cars with lights and every kind of Halloween decoration you can find. My parents congregation has a traditional chili dinner and a contest for the best decorated vehicle. (One note about their congregation, Half of the people live in one neighborhood and the other half lives 5 miles up a canyon. Their Halloween party has been going on since before the September 11th attacks and was born out of logistcs concerns.) Different from a Halloween Party,
TRUNK-or-Treat is meant to be a
substitute for the traditional
TRICK-or-Treating. Looking through the picture files has shown a HUGELY wide variety of levels that this kind of Halloween celebration is taken to. The city-wide celebrations sound like a blast. The church-wide celebrations, be it Methodist, Baptist or LDS, look fun, boring, or anywhere in-between the two.
Halloween in 2008 was our first year living in Ogden, Ut. Ogden, a city that has had troubles with gangs, drugs and prostitutes but has also rebounded in the past several years through the efforts of the city officials and the community. Ogden is a beautiful city at the base of the Wasatch Mountain Range and is known for it's recreational opportunities. While the gang and drug problems still exist and the Latino population inhabits a large part of the inner-city limits (cited as an example of the language barrier only), a great portion of the city consists of quiet neighborhoods lined with large trees. The first Halloween we spent in Ogden was full of hopes of a good time walking with the children to collect their candy. Our congregation joined with another that meets in our building and held a hap-hazard 'Trunk-or-Treat' in the parking lot. When I say hap-hazard, I am referring to the lack of Halloween-ness. No dinner or refreshments, no decorations, just lots and lots of kids grabbing their candy and, 20 minutes later, heading home. LAME-O!! What's fun about that? 20 minutes and then finished for the night. Now, I want to say here that I am not picking on our own congregation, and especially not the church itself. I am also not mounting a personal attack on any of the members of our congregation (many of whom are dear friends). My concerns are not personal, rather communal. They are not about a single person or clergy or congregation, rather they are about our nation as a whole. The LDS and the Non-LDS, the race majority and the race minority. The whole community, as I have come to understand during the past 24 hrs.
October 31st, 2009 Halloween Night. Ogden, UT. 84403
My oldest has been sick this week with the dreaded swine flu. It's been a long week taking care of all four kids and not having felt well myself. I never seem to do well when our routine is thrown off. It is often said that children thrive on consistency, but I have to add that parents do too! I've been thinking all month about having a few friends over for dinner before heading out to take the kids trick-or-treating. I thought it would be so fun to make chili and serve it in one of the huge pumpkins that have spent the last month on our front porch and have our friends each bring some kind of Halloween-themed dish. I've talked to a couple of friends who are waiting, along with me, to see if my oldest recovers soon enough to not infect all of our guests.
24 hrs before we should be starting the party and my child still has a fever. The party is a no-go and after the week I've had I really don't care if the holiday happens at all. Unfortunately for me, I can't disappoint my kids by not doing anything. There is a part of me that wishes that I didn't care so much, it would be so nice to feed them dinner and put them all in bed. I can hear my P.J.'s calling my name, it's the same sound I've heard since...Wednesday, and it's getting louder and louder! With no religious signifigance there is little pull for me to get it on at this point in the game. My husband and I have talked about giving in and taking the kids to the 'Trunk-or-Treat' just to get it over with and really, in my head, it's decided. As I walk sluggishly around Costco for my bi-weekly shopping trip I am struck with an ounce of regret for two reasons: One, I don't really think I can make it home in time for the tunk-or-treat, and two, I HATE the Trunk-or-Treat! Can I really give into that cop-out? I dialed my husbands number and asked him to have the kids vote, it's one or the other but not both, TRUNK or TRICK. When he calls me back he says that the vote is unanimous - The kids want to go TRICK-or Treating.
In the end, it was a crazy but satisfying evening for our whole family. The craziness stemed from throwing together costumes, getting everyone dinner, taking pictures, loading a crying baby into the stroller and then finding a costume piece to fit our new dog. The satisfying part of the evening came from visiting with the neighbors that were home, running from house to house to house in the crisp yet pleasant autumn air, collecting several handfuls of candy and arriving home to warm baths, happy children and good memories.

Without involving the kids in our complaining, I, along with the neighbors I spoke to, wondered at the lack of families wandering the street. We contemplated what had happened to the days that we rememberd as children and we chuckled as we thought about how much candy would be sitting in our homes, not handed out to the children it had been purchased for. It is still sad for me as I sit writing this and I wonder if I should just resign myself to the way things are and accept the memories of my childhood as one more chapter to add to the book of the Good 'Ol Days. The days when parents didn't worry about the sex-offender down the street, or about their kids walking to school alone, or trans fat. For goodness sake! I am only 31 and yet it seems like another world, that world that I grew up in. Has Halloween really become a thing of the past?
No. Wow. After all of that poetic justice paid to our holiday of this past weekend, the answer is NO? What evidence could I have possibly collected in 12 hours? Mwahahaha....just read and see.....
I spent a lovely hour on the phone with my sweet sister-in-law this afternoon. She had called to wish me a happy birthday and we spent the hour talking about, everything. Mina told me that a group of their wards had held a Halloween Carnival for the community that was outstanding and had gone from 12:30-3:00pm (?) on Halloween. Then, she and Derek and the kids had dinner with some friends before going out trick-or-treating. When I asked if their had been very many kids out that night, she sounded surprised that I would even ask and responded with an upbeat 'yes'! Mina lives in Denver, Colorado. She told me that allthough the schools were closed Mon-Wed because of snow (in October!!) the snow had melted off enough that the streets and sidewalks were clear and the temperatures were relatively warm. Interesting. We reminiced about taking our families trick-or-treating together the year before they moved to CO. We had walked through her neighborhood in Farmington, UT. and had so much fun, especially at that house that had a table set up with donughts and hot-chocolate...it must be a City thing in Utah...
A while later I spoke to my "baby" brother who is living in Washington D.C. while interning at the Foriegn Service. I asked him if he saw kids trick-or-treating in D.C. and he said YES. What?! In D.C? Surely not, but he assured me that he had, of course it was in a residential neighborhood, but yes.
In the NATIONS CAPITAL, kids are still trick-or-treating. Amazing!
Now I know, at least in part. Halloween isn't gone, it's just hiding. My guess is that those that are stuck don't realize the impact it's having. Here's to hoping that we can find it before next year. Here's hoping that we can find our sense of community again in the streets of Utah or anywhere our brothers and sisters call home. Texas, Alaska, anywhere - in quiet towns like Spanish Fork, and less quiet towns like Ogden. If there is some chance you are reading this, let me know what you think. What has your experince been this year and in years past? Do you think that our communities have forgotten or do you think that we just found an easy out after 2001 and we are stuck in a rut? Is this a problem (or not) in only LDS communities? I'll be interested to hear what you have to say.